Request: Aydz - Aydz

[Cobaltsaber]

Request a Ban

Accused User's name

Aydz

Accused SteamID

Aydz

Date of Infraction

18 December 2010

Time of Infraction

5-10pm

Map Played During Infraction

minecraft

On which server did the infraction take place?

Other

What happened?

On TNR's minecraft server my house was greifed, I have many pictures and firm evidence to support it wasn't a greifer and to point toward one individual.


Upon logging in I saw most of my area ravaged by a hole, this hole was just outside my warehouse suggesting someone was trying to get inside when the creeper exploded, inside I was missing many items including my glass , some flint and steels and my obsidian. After asking Aydz if he knew what happened near my town as he and 2 others are the only people who knew it was there.He replied with a long "blame it on the creeper".

looking around I found missing water on my fields, my plants are all taken( not afew like they were trampled but ALL of them) and the trunks cut out of most of the surrounding trees. Since Aydz was the only one within gaming access for that weekend I blamed him and he denied it and said something along the lines of "the creeper also burned the forest, its wonderful"

Continuing to look around I found a huge cobble stone house, I have to stress here that it was cobblestone and wood and the chests inside contained nothing but stone tools. This house was built by someone who had no idea what they were doing, but in this house afew things interested me. Scattered around was obsidian and glass; both materials missing from my chest, how could someone working with stone and wood get obsidian and glass?

Next to this house was a burning forest, a forest mentioned by Aydz earlier in the session, I find it no coincidence that within the time i was offline my house was greifed and a new one built a small distance away next to a burning forest mentioned by one of the 2 people who know were the area is.

After posting on the minecraft thread with
"I had someone greif my area too, I think I know who it is but I would rather get some actual evidence before wailing on him"

He replied almost instantly with
"creepers make it very easy to point fingers... creepers have blown up my house a ridiculous amount of times.. manophat, i think you should disable creepers as they just kinda blow shit up"

Pretty defensive for someone who has done nothing wrong?
I have pictures to support all of these claims and I accuse aydz of greifing the TNR minecraft server.

/end rant

[manofphat]

A lot of your post is speculation.
Please include the screenshots that you mentioned.

---------- Post added at 11:41 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:30 AM ----------

Also, isn't Aydz one of your friends?

[Derfel]

Just an aside - after the posts in the Minecraft thread, I logged in to the server - Aydz was online at that time. I walked around in montyville and checked out what I think is cobalt's house there - most of it seemed okay, but it was obviously someone had broken a few of his chests - all the blocks around them were intact, but there were floating stacks of cobblestone and gravel there. I wouldn't guess a creeper could have done that.

[Cobaltsaber]

to derfel's post, it wasent my house in montyville, he was one of my friends and thats why he was one on the 2 people who know were it was. the hole was not a creeper explosion unless the creeper somehow went off in a pit; the shape was irregular and there was a slight overhang of blocks above the hole.

[Cobaltsaber]

screenshots


First, remember the comment near the top, it will come around later



Look at the shape of the hole, in addition, the only thing inside that building were chests, all of which are missing mats.



All the trees were cut out, wood is an easy to get and thus "newbie" building item.




continuing in that direction I find a new house made of cobblestone, also a "newbie material". Considering the greifer made the house a monolith of cobblestone he was obviously not concerned with aesthetics or made it in a short amount of time, were did he get the glass for a roof then?



Inside we find more signs it is a new player, stone tools and dirt in the chests. What I didnt find was the mine were all of these materials came from.




Rembering this is a player who doesent know what his is doing and hasent had a very long server presence, how in hell did he get this?




Now remember the comment earlier about the burning forest? here it is to prove this house belongs to aydz


So we know the house belongs to the greifer based on the glass and the obsidian which he most likely threw down accidentally and didnt have the tools to pick back up but it is not enough to prove it is aydz, but then I got this



Notice how he practically accepts it was him, and then I got this, accepting ownership of the house in question



You must remember that I know aydz personally IRL, we had a falling out the night before and it was most likely the reason he did it.

[manofphat]

Aydz isn't the only person in that big house beside yours. There are two others as well.

[Cobaltsaber]

The 2 others are his 2 friends who I also know personally. They were not involved in the argument between him and I and I dont believe they would take part in griefing.

[MiNdWaRp]

"idgaf, he can seee the server history" doesn't sound like a denial on his part. He pretty much admitted to doing it through that.

[Aydz]

I have not admitted to anything. I made a small shelter, expanded it into a house. On my way to my shelter, a creeper followed me, destroying a small part of cobalt's house. I had attempted to reach him through steam acknowledging this, and I got no response. I asked if I could help rebuild it, he continued being aggressive towards me.
As for the trees, I am a complete "scrub" at Minecraft. I took the wood out of a tree, and Cobalt had once said to "burn the leaves". I did that, attempting to clean up this area near Montyville. The fire spread, I apologized. Nothing was burnt of value.
Cobalt later had said that I intentionally burned any items of value in his possession. I strongly oppose to this, and I am extremely offended at his lack of common sense. After realizing I had caused a "problem", I immediately took off to a remote area outside of Montyville. Out of reach, out of the way.
I believe that there is a strong amount of bias in Cobalt's argument, and I believe the ban should not withstand.
Sorry for Formality
Aydz

[0ptik]

Honestly, i dont see his comment as admitting anything. Its more sarcasm cause he knows you are blaming him.